After much deliberation, WorthPlaying staffers have nominated 17 games for "Best of E3 2014" awards. Read on to find out which games caught our eye, and check back Friday to read about the five coveted finalists!

Unlike the previous adventures of Sherlock Holmes, in Crimes & Punishments, you are not a mere spectator during the detective's investigation. It is now your turn to become Sherlock Holmes and lead your own investigations.